Tips for Thought

Their Eyes Were Watching God: A Deep Dive into Zora Neale Hurston’s Masterpiece

“Their Eyes Were Watching God,” a timeless classic published in 1937, is perhaps one of the most impactful works from the Harlem Renaissance writer, Zora Neale Hurston. The novel encapsulates Hurston’s unique ability to blend Southern folk tradition with an exploration of black women’s experiences in a racially and gender-segregated society.

The story is set in the 1930s rural Florida, revolving around the life of an African American woman, Janie Crawford. It begins with a middle-aged Janie returning to Eatonville after a lengthy absence, stirring curiosity among the townsfolk. Her close friend, Pheoby Watson, acts as a sounding board as Janie recounts her life’s journey in an extended flashback.

Janie’s journey to self-discovery and independence is mapped out through her three marriages. Her first marriage to Logan Killicks, an older farmer, is arranged by her grandmother, who believes this will ensure Janie’s protection and stability. However, Janie soon realizes that she feels no love for Logan, leading her to run away with the smooth-talking and ambitious Joe “Jody” Starks.

In her second marriage, Janie becomes Mrs. Starks, the First Lady of Eatonville, a town founded and governed by Joe. Despite the respect and luxury she enjoys, Janie feels stifled under Joe’s authoritarian rule, and her identity is suppressed. Joe’s death frees Janie, and she embraces her newfound independence, only to be swept off her feet by Tea Cake Woods, a much younger man who represents love, freedom, and a sense of adventure.

Through a catastrophic hurricane, personal loss, and a dramatic trial, Janie’s journey comes full circle as she returns to Eatonville, ready to confront the gossips and judgmental townspeople with the wisdom and strength she has gleaned from her life experiences.

Lessons from the Novel

“Their Eyes Were Watching God” is rich with life lessons, captured beautifully within the metaphor-laden vernacular that is Hurston’s signature style.

The Pursuit of Self-Identity and Autonomy

One of the most profound lessons from Hurston’s narrative is the importance of personal autonomy and self-identity. Janie’s journey symbolizes every woman’s quest for self-determination. She moves from a silent young girl, expected to fulfill roles dictated by society and her partners, to a self-empowered woman who breaks free from societal norms and claims her identity.

Love as a Source of Freedom

Through Janie’s relationships, Hurston portrays love as a source of freedom rather than a bondage. While her first two marriages are devoid of passion and confine her to societal expectations, her relationship with Tea Cake, marked by mutual respect and equality, frees her from her metaphorical muzzles. It teaches us that love should be liberating, allowing the space for individuals to grow and express themselves fully.

Resilience in the Face of Adversity

Janie’s life is marked by hardships and trials, yet she exhibits extraordinary resilience. From her loveless first marriage and repressive second one, to losing her beloved Tea Cake and standing trial for his death, Janie endures. Her journey is a testament to the human spirit’s resilience, showing us that adversity can be faced and overcome, often leading to profound personal growth.

The Importance of Storytelling and Personal Narratives

Hurston brilliantly uses the act of storytelling to assert power over personal narratives. When Janie returns to Eatonville, she chooses to share her story on her own terms, redefining her identity to the townsfolk. In a world often too eager to impose narratives on individuals, particularly women, the book emphasizes the importance of reclaiming and owning one’s story.


“Their Eyes Were Watching God” is not merely a novel; it is an exploration of life, a masterclass in storytelling, a celebration of dialect and folk wisdom, and above all, a tribute to black womanhood. Janie’s story is a journey of self-discovery that defies societal expectations, offering profound lessons on autonomy, love, resilience, and the power of personal narratives. Hurston’s masterpiece remains a relevant and powerful text, engaging readers with its timeless wisdom and beautifully intricate portrayal of a black woman’s life.